#GPS#GLONASS#Galileo#BeiDou#GNSS#satellite

GPS vs GLONASS vs Galileo vs BeiDou: The Four Global Navigation Systems Compared

GPS is just one of four global satellite navigation systems. Compare GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, and BeiDou (orbits, satellite counts, civil signals), plus QZSS, NavIC, and correction methods like SBAS, RTK, PPK, and PPP.

by 9 min readLast reviewed

"GPS" has become the everyday word for satellite navigation, but the American GPS is only one of four global systems, and your phone almost certainly uses several of them at once. The umbrella term is GNSS: Global Navigation Satellite System. This guide compares the four systems using figures from their operators' own websites, covers the two regional systems, explains why multi-system receivers are more reliable, and walks through the correction methods (SBAS, RTK, PPK, PPP) that take accuracy from meters down to centimeters.

All four share the design we covered in how GPS works: satellites with precise clocks broadcast one-way ranging signals, and a receiver solves for its position from the distances to at least four satellites. The differences are in orbits, signals, and extra services.

The Four Systems at a Glance

GPSGLONASSGalileoBeiDou (BDS-3)
OperatorUnited States (U.S. Space Force)RussiaEuropean UnionChina
Main orbitMEO, ~20,200 kmMEO, 19,100 km nominalMEO, ~23,200 km (semi-major axis 29,599.8 km)MEO at 21,528 km, plus GEO and IGSO at 35,786 km
Design6 orbital planes, 24 baseline slots (operated as 27)24 satellites in 3 planes, 64.8° inclination24 nominal satellites in 3 planes, 56° inclination24 MEO + 3 GEO + 3 IGSO nominal, 55° inclination
Operational satellites31 (as of July 3, 2023)24 in operation, 29 in constellation (as of Nov 12, 2026)28 "USABLE" of 32 listed (checked Nov 13, 2026)45 in-orbit service satellites: 30 BDS-3 + 15 BDS-2 (as of May 2021)

Sources for each figure are listed at the end of this article. These numbers change as satellites launch and retire, so each one comes with the date of its source. The GPS and BeiDou numbers are the latest that their official sites publish on the pages linked below. They are not live counts.

The numbers need some interpretation. GPS.gov says the U.S. commits to at least 24 operational satellites 95% of the time, and that the Space Force "has been flying 31 operational GPS satellites for well over a decade." The extra satellites improve coverage but are not part of the core constellation. GLONASS's monitoring center separates satellites "in operation" (24) from those under check by the prime contractor (5). Galileo's service center marks each satellite as USABLE or NOT USABLE. On the day I checked, four were listed as not usable.

What Makes Each One Distinct

GPS is the reference system. Every consumer receiver supports it. GPS.gov describes four civil signals: the legacy L1 C/A, plus three modernized ones. L2C (1227 MHz) lets dual-frequency receivers correct ionospheric delay. L5 (1176 MHz) sits in a band protected for aviation safety and has higher power and bandwidth. L1C was designed with Europe as a common civil signal for GPS and Galileo. GPS.gov still labels L2C and L5 "pre-operational."

GLONASS traditionally used FDMA: each satellite transmits on its own frequency, while the other systems tell satellites apart by code. Its constellation is 24 satellites in three planes inclined at 64.8°. GPS, Galileo, and BeiDou's MEO satellites use 55–56°. A steeper inclination takes satellites farther toward the poles, so GLONASS helps fill gaps in the sky at high northern latitudes.

Galileo is the European system. Its service center lists open signals on E1, E5a, E5b, and E6. Its standout feature for ordinary users is the High Accuracy Service (HAS), declared at initial service on January 24, 2023. HAS sends free precise orbit and clock corrections through the Galileo E6-B signal and over the internet, and a compatible receiver uses them for Precise Point Positioning (explained below).

BeiDou grew from a China-only system (BDS-1, in use 2000) to an Asia-Pacific one (BDS-2, 2012) and then a global one (BDS-3, completed 2020). Its constellation is a hybrid. On top of the standard MEO satellites, it keeps geostationary and inclined-geosynchronous satellites high over Asia, which China's navigation office says gives better coverage in obstructed, low-latitude areas. Open signals include B1I, B1C, B2a, B2b, and B3I. B2a sits at 1176.45 MHz, the same center frequency as GPS L5, which makes dual-system receivers easier to build. BeiDou also offers services the others don't, including short-message communication and a free PPP service (PPP-B2b) broadcast from its GEO satellites over China and nearby regions. Its 2021 report gives measured global accuracy as better than 2.5 m horizontal and 5.0 m vertical.

Regional Systems: QZSS and NavIC

Two more systems cover only part of the world.

  • QZSS (Japan) uses satellites in orbits that keep one of them high in the sky ("quasi-zenith") over Japan. That helps in deep urban canyons, where only a near-vertical line of sight is open. It also broadcasts L1C-like signals compatible with GPS. GPS.gov notes that QZSS and BeiDou are both adopting L1C-like signals.
  • NavIC (India) covers India and the surrounding region. The global IGS network tracks NavIC alongside the other systems.

Why Multi-GNSS Receivers Help

Open a GNSS status app on a recent phone and you will often see satellites from three or four systems tracked together. Combining systems helps in three ways.

  1. More satellites. A position needs at least four satellites. With one system you might see 8–12 in open sky. With four systems the pool is several times larger, so losing a few still leaves enough.
  2. Better geometry (DOP). Accuracy depends on how spread out the satellites are, not just how many there are. Dilution of precision (DOP) measures this. Satellites clustered in one part of the sky give a high DOP, which magnifies every ranging error. Satellites spread in all directions give a low DOP. More satellites from different orbital planes make a low DOP far more likely. For example, BeiDou's ground augmentation service sets its accuracy specification under the condition PDOP ≤ 2 with at least six usable satellites.
  3. Resilience and cross-checks. In a street lined with tall buildings, half the sky may be blocked. A single system might drop below four usable satellites, while several systems combined still leave enough. Receivers can also compare systems to catch a bad measurement.

Some errors remain whatever the satellite count: ionospheric and tropospheric delay, signals reflected off buildings (multipath), and obstructions. We break these down in what affects GPS accuracy. Dual-frequency receivers (for example L1 + L5) remove most of the ionospheric part, which is why GPS.gov calls L2C and L5 accuracy upgrades.

Try it on My Location: compare a fix in open sky with one next to a tall building.

For what it's worth, I have never manually switched which constellations a receiver uses. Modern receivers combine them automatically, and the accuracy work I have done relied on the correction methods below.

Correction Methods: SBAS, RTK, PPK, and PPP

Multi-GNSS mainly improves availability and geometry. To go from meters to decimeters or centimeters, receivers apply corrections. The four common approaches are:

SBAS (Satellite-Based Augmentation System). Ground reference stations measure GNSS errors over a large region. The system then broadcasts corrections and integrity warnings through geostationary satellites on a GPS-like signal, so an ordinary receiver can pick them up. GPS.gov describes WAAS, run by the U.S. FAA for aviation across North America, as interoperable with Japan's MSAS, Europe's EGNOS, and India's GAGAN. BeiDou provides its own SBAS for China and nearby regions. SBAS improves accuracy and integrity at the meter level and needs no extra equipment.

RTK (Real-Time Kinematic). A base station at a precisely known point sits nearby (or a network of reference stations serves the area). It streams its raw measurements to the moving receiver, often called the rover, in real time. The rover compares the carrier phase of the satellite signals at both receivers and cancels the errors they share, giving centimeter-level positions as long as the correction link stays up and the base is close. BeiDou's ground augmentation service, for instance, specifies horizontal accuracy of 4 cm or better (RMS) under good conditions.

PPK (Post-Processed Kinematic). This uses the same carrier-phase math as RTK, but the base and rover simply log data during the job and the corrections are computed afterward. There is no live radio or internet link to lose. A related public service in the U.S. is NOAA's OPUS, which GPS.gov says post-processes GPS data to the centimeter level using the CORS network of nearly 2,000 stations.

PPP (Precise Point Positioning). PPP needs no nearby base station. The receiver applies precise satellite orbit and clock corrections, computed from a global network, to its own measurements. It works anywhere, but the solution takes time to settle. Galileo HAS and BeiDou PPP-B2b both broadcast PPP corrections free from the satellites themselves. BeiDou's 2021 report gives measured PPP-B2b accuracy of better than 20 cm horizontal and 35 cm vertical, with 15–20 minutes to converge.

In my own work I build ground control software for drones. When I had to deal with drone position errors, I relied on RTK and PPK. Both work by comparing the drone's measurements with those of a reference receiver at a known point.

One Output, Many Inputs

Whichever satellites and corrections go into a fix, the receiver reports the result as latitude and longitude, usually in WGS84. From there you can express the fix in DD, DMS, or DDM, project it into UTM, or measure distances between fixes. To check what your device reports right now, use the GPS coordinates finder or My Location.

Sources

Related Posts

#GPS#satellite#trilateration

How GPS Actually Works: Satellites, Signals, and Trilateration

A clear explanation of how GPS determines your position: the satellite constellation, radio signals traveling at light speed, atomic clocks, relativity corrections, and why you need at least four satellites.

8 min read
Read More
#GPS#accuracy#satellite

How Accurate Is GPS? Real Numbers: 5 m on Phones, 1 cm with RTK

How accurate is GPS? Typically about 5 meters on smartphones — down to centimeters with RTK. See accuracy by device type and the factors that degrade it, with practical tips.

13 min read
Read More
#GPS#altitude#elevation

Why GPS Altitude Is So Inaccurate (and What the Numbers Actually Mean)

GPS vertical error is larger than horizontal error, and the height your device shows may be measured from an ellipsoid that sits tens of meters away from sea level. Here are the geometry, the geoid, worked Seoul and New York examples, and a practical checklist.

8 min read
Read More